Troll Kingdom
This is a sample guest message. Register a free account today to become a member! Once signed in, you'll be able to participate on this site by adding your own topics and posts, as well as connect with other members through your own private inbox!
Jack the Giant Slayer
- Thread starter eloisel
- Start date
kaonashi.shinu
Keeper of the Nether Eye
I've heard good things and the reviews have been good (though I rarely trust those nowadays). Does it basically follow the folktale or have they swerved far from the origins?
eloisel
Forever Empress E
Well, that is the problem with stories such as that. I heard it as a child. I told it to my kids. So, the story is familiar. There was a lot added to it that was not out of line or wrecked the familiarity. This movie gives a little more substance to the magic beans with some back story I don't remember from tales I've heard. Jack doesn't go alone up the beanstalk and he has more reason to go than just to climb the thing and see what is there. He also seems a bit daft at first but turns out to be fairly clever and quite brave. I liked that. Not a lot I can say without giving the story away.
The reviews I've seen are mixed. One organization declared the movie bombed. Plus, it is only getting 3.5 stars. I'd give it at least a 4. It is visually very good in Imax 3D. I'd have given it a higher rating except it is not original.
Keep in mind, I liked John Carter and the industry panned the heck out of it. I also liked the last Twilight movie and the critics gave it all kinds of razzie awards. Maybe I am not the audience the critics review movies for.
The reviews I've seen are mixed. One organization declared the movie bombed. Plus, it is only getting 3.5 stars. I'd give it at least a 4. It is visually very good in Imax 3D. I'd have given it a higher rating except it is not original.
Keep in mind, I liked John Carter and the industry panned the heck out of it. I also liked the last Twilight movie and the critics gave it all kinds of razzie awards. Maybe I am not the audience the critics review movies for.
Enkephalen
My Stars!
Rotten Tomatoes gives it a 52% by reviewers and 64% by audiences.
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/jack_the_giant_slayer/
I'll wait and rent the movie or when it comes on DirecTV.
http://www.rottentomatoes.com/m/jack_the_giant_slayer/
I'll wait and rent the movie or when it comes on DirecTV.
eloisel
Forever Empress E
I don't agree with their assessment. It was quite enjoyable on a big screen.
However, if you have limited cash and time, then save yours for the new Oz movie. Saw it today and love it. I think it will become a classic. I don't care what the critics say. They are just mean, hateful people who have to be ugly about everything to make themselves feel better about themselves.
However, if you have limited cash and time, then save yours for the new Oz movie. Saw it today and love it. I think it will become a classic. I don't care what the critics say. They are just mean, hateful people who have to be ugly about everything to make themselves feel better about themselves.