I’ve been rewatching the movies lately. Last week was The Final Frontier, followed by Generations a few days later.
Man, TFF is sooo much better than I remembered! It’s got so much heart, so many good character moments, and the plot is fine really. The addition of the Klingons is unnecessary, but Sybok is a refreshingly complex “villain”. For once it’s not someone who callously wants to kill everybody, he actually has good intentions, but is misguided in how he goes about fulfilling them.
I could have done without the crowbarred in romance between Uhura and Scotty, but things like the turbolift scene people often complain about really aren’t that bad if you take them in the spirit they were intended.
Generations on the other hand, just felt like quite a mishmash of ideas that didn’t spend enough time on any one plot point to really do it justice. While TTF has a clear message that your mistakes are an important part of you and your development, I’m not really sure what moral Generations was trying to impart. Picard and Kirk both have regrets about sticking to their duty at the expense of having families. And through a magic time portal they get to do the same thing they always do.