Voyager was amazing. It was magical. TNG went out on a high with "All Good Things" (which was actually kind of stupid now that I rewatch it--but I digress). Trekkies LOVED the franchise. This was still in the era of direct syndication and they rolled out DS9. It had some things going for it but around this time Paramount decided to do their own network and TPTB liked the idea of a ship, flyin' around, so they came up with VOY, which had an interesting premise, nice sets and costumes etc. So I watched it. And watched it. And watched it. Around the time they had the ship land on a planet and the crew was captured and enslaved or something something in the back of my head started to go "does this suck?" It did. And it just continued to go downhill week after week. Back when TNG was first run you'd sit right up to the "Next time on an all-new Star Trek:TNG" and go "OMG! SCOTTY!" That hour of your week was permanently blocked out. There was a point in VOY where you'd go "oh, I missed VOY. Oh well." I remember me and my roommate actually watching the finale though and going "meh."
Then ENT was coming. The premise was amazing. (ENT was actually how I wound up here, in the long run. It was impossible to e-mail Paramount about Star Trek so I joined the official Star Trek message board. It was crap so I drifted to Subspace, then TBBS, WF, and eventually here.) My roommate and me talked about it and settled in to watch the premiere. "How long do you think before we encounter the Klingons?" I asked. The credits ended and next thing you know, there's a Klingon. "Well, there's your answer," my roommate said. I watched the first few episodes, then caught the last few episodes of the 1st season and the first few of the 2nd and said "well, this is as good as this show is ever going to get" and it wasn't very good. I did watch the Manny Coto final season and it was an improvement but not as amazing as everyone made it out to be. And of course we got the Bermaga finale.